Secretariat

Anna Frerck
Institute of International Forestry and Forest Economics

Leuschnerstraße 91
21031 Hamburg-Bergedorf
Phone: +49 40 739 62 301
Fax: +49 40 739 62 399
wf@thuenen.de


Deforestation-free supply chains – Opportunities & Limits of private sector's initiatives

Project

 (c) PSU-Terry D. Etherton

Deforestation-free supply chains – Opportunities & Limits of private sector's initiatives

The deforestation-free production of agricultural commodities has moved into the focus of civil society since the connection between industrial agriculture and the loss of tropical forests has reached public awareness.

Background and Objective

A study for the European Commission (2013) analysed “The impact of EU consumption on deforestation” for crop, livestock and wood products. The study highlighted inter alia the role of the EU27 in the global trade of soy, where the European Union imports 60% of Brazilian and 50% of Argentinian soy exports - both countries where soy is one of the most important drivers of deforestation. With the Amsterdam Declaration in 2015, the German government together with other European countries declared their willingness to support the private sector’s goal to eliminate deforestation from agricultural supply chains by 2020.

One objective of this project is to evaluate whether certification standards are appropriate for the target of stopping deforestation. Furthermore, we aim at identifying synergies and challenges of the potential linkage of different concepts aiming at reducing deforestation and try to provide solutions.

Approach

The production of soy is an important driver for the deforestation of primary forests, especially in Brazil. The European Union, and in particular Germany, is a relevant importer of soy and thereby indirectly contributes to the ongoing deforestation. Usually companies use certification schemes to ensure deforestation-free sourcing and in general the compliance with social or ecological requirements. Our analysis of those soy certification schemes that are compliant with the Soy Sourcing Guidelines of the European Feed Manufacturers' Federation (FEFAC) has shown that requirements between the schemes are quite different.

Preliminary Results

In joint collaboration with the Thünen Institute of Market Analysis, we evaluated the FEFAC compliant standards regarding their requirements for conservation of natural ecosystems, good agricultural practice, social criteria, auditing and traceability systems. We identified ISCC PLUS and ISCC EU as the schemes with the highest overall scores. ProTerra and RTRS have high requirements in place, as well. These certification schemes are in line with the political goals of the Amsterdam Declaration, but also with the voluntary commitments of relevant private sector organizations and business networks, such as the Consumer Goods Forum.

  • Project brief 2020/14 (DE) Yvonne Hargita
    DOI:103220/PB1587381727000
  • Project brief 2020/14a (EN) Yvonne Hargita
    DOI:103220/PB1587381393000

Links and Downloads

New York Declaration on Forests

Amsterdam Declaration

The impact of EU consumption on deforestation

BMEL Internationale Forest Policy

Project Side Thünen Institute of Market Analysis

Thünen-Contact


Involved Thünen-Partners


Duration

6.2017 - 12.2020

More Information

Projekt type:
Project status: ongoing

List of Publications

hits: 5

  1. Hargita Y, Giessen L, Günter S (2020) Primärwaldverlust bis 2030 stoppen: UNFCCC REDD+ und Entwaldungsfreie Lieferketten. Hamburg: Thünen-Institut für Internationale Waldwirtschaft und Forstökonomie, 1 p, Project Brief Thünen Inst 2020/14, DOI:10.3220/PB1587381727000
    pdf document (limited accessibility) 260 kb
  2. Hargita Y, Giessen L, Günter S (2020) Similarities and differences between international REDD+ and transnational deforestation-free supply chain initiatives - a review. Sustainability 12(3):896, DOI:10.3390/su12030896
    pdf document (limited accessibility) 471 kb
  3. Hargita Y, Giessen L, Günter S (2020) Towards ending natural forest loss by 2030: UNFCCC REDD+ and deforestation-free supply chains. Hamburg: Thünen Institute of International Forestry and Forest Economics, 1 p, Project Brief Thünen Inst 2020/14a, DOI:10.3220/PB1587381393000
    pdf document (limited accessibility) 231 kb
  4. Hargita Y, Bick U (2019) Assessment of FEFAC-compliant certification schemes for deforestation-free soy and evaluation towards the goals of the NYDF and the AD. Schr Gesellsch Wirtsch Sozialwiss Landbaues 54:307-318
  5. Hargita Y, Hinkes C, Bick U, Peter G (2019) Entwaldungsfreie Agrarrohstoffe - Analyse relevanter Soja-Zertifizierungssysteme für Futtermittel. Korrigierte Auflage. Braunschweig: Johann Heinrich von Thünen-Institut, 86 p, Thünen Working Paper 98, DOI:10.3220/WP1575275224000
    pdf document (limited accessibility) 2259 kb